A Book A Week

Think back to the early months of 2020. COVID-19 was on the rise as a global health crisis, incidents of police brutality were escalating, and America was led by a president who stood out as one of the most polarizing figures in history. The atmosphere was thick with uncertainty. At a time when many sought strong and compassionate leadership, we found ourselves with a leader more focused on personal gain than on serving the nation. During such periods of uncertainty, it's natural for our minds to wander and ponder alternative realities. I found myself wondering, "What if things had been different?" Author Curtis Sittenfeld seized upon this speculative thought, channeling it into her novel, Rodham.

Hillary Rodham Clinton is one of the most influential women in American political history. Regardless of one's opinion on her political beliefs, her impact on the nation's political landscape is undeniable. She's a figure who has consistently evoked strong reactions since her days as First Lady during Bill Clinton's landmark presidency. While many are familiar with the disappointment of her 2016 presidential loss to Donald Trump, Curtis Sittenfeld has imagined an intriguing alternative history. In the novel, Hillary Rodham, having declined Bill Clinton's marriage proposal, chooses a path that diverges from her eventual union with the former president. This alternate narrative prompts readers to reflect on the potential trajectory of one of America's most prominent political figures had she taken a different route.

The initial sections of Rodham closely mirror Hillary's known history. We witness her early law school years, and indeed, her relationship with Bill Clinton develops much as it did in reality. In many respects, they make an unusual pair. Bill is exuberant and effortlessly establishes genuine rapport with people, often forming connections with those he's just met. On the other hand, Hillary is more introspective, finding solace and comfort within her tight-knit circle of friends rather than in new acquaintances. Yet, the two are undeniably drawn to each other, each possessing a brilliant intellect and curiosity that perfectly complements the other's temperament. Hinting at the public marital challenges they faced in real life, Bill grapples with infidelity in this fictional account, even as his political ambitions start to take shape. At this point, Sittenfeld's narrative veers away from known history. Bill and Hillary do not wed; instead, they embark on separate paths that will eventually intersect, but in ways starkly different from the history we know.

Within this alternative historical timeline, Sittenfeld's Rodham primarily unfolds. Liberated from her relationship with Bill, Hillary ventures into a political career where she seizes control of her own narrative, something she could not fully achieve in real life. Presented in the first person, the novel resonates with the authenticity of a genuine memoir, offering readers intimate insights into Hillary's political and personal ambitions. Sittenfeld provides a form of wish fulfillment, granting Hillary the opportunities many of us wished she had experienced. Much of this imagined narrative aligns closely with the fringes of actual history, lending the fabricated events a sense of credibility that makes them feel believable, even though they never transpired. Hillary faces many of the same obstacles she encountered in real life, particularly as she contemplates a presidential run. The challenges of being a woman in a predominantly male role are eternally evident. Sittenfeld adeptly captures the aspirations and frustrations of a woman poised for greatness if only the course of history would accommodate her. Although the conclusion may seem somewhat predictable, Rodham remains a captivating read that ignites the imagination.

For more information, visit the author's website, Amazon, and Goodreads. 

(2024, 27)